IIRC a few years back someone on the forum who had to shuffle customers about argued that a too spiffy car was not a good thing for a salesman. Was it Wetson?
So maybe a CPO car of one generation back would be right and that would, to me, point to an Accord, Camry or Avalon.
On the other hand...at 40-50K kms a year a new car won't look new for long anyway.