great comparo guys!
thanks.
i would take GTI, no question.
That's what I thought too going in.
I'm on Jeff's side with the GTI. It is too polished & refined - if that is what turns you on, you'll love the GTI... but for me, a good chunk of the car's capability is muted out. Because of all that, i'd choose the DSG here instead of the 6 speed. In fact, i'd probably take the Mini over the GTI... it is more like a GTI now, and I think does a better job of it.
I fell ridiculously in love with the WRX. It is a more raw/engaging experience - the clutch & shifter take a deliberate shove & is by far the fastest car in the test. That 2.0T engine is an awesome unit. Easily won the fun to drive category for me.
If I could have only one do it all car, it would be the WRX. If I were buying a second car whose primary mission is fun, it would probably be the MX-5.