I've obviously never driven both, and while initially I was leaning to the Vette as far as the car I would "choose", I think that I'm now leaning towards the Cayman. And certainly not because of the Edmunds comparo......No question that I love the looks of the Cayman over the Vette. I just can't warm up to the Vette's rear profile at all yet. Having owned an S2000 for four years now and experiencing how much of a driver's car this is, it appears that the Cayman is more similar compared to the Vette. And that means more to mean than any 0-60, 1/4 mile, or track numbers etc that I won't have a chance to duplicate in daily driving. Seems like the Cayman would be a better fit for me.