I still consider myself an enthusiast and Corolla is my daily driver. I'm interested in cars for different reasons perhaps... it's "nice" of people to ascribe their viewpoints on others.
Regardless of anything... decided to do a little comparison on purely enthusiast levels of three cars in the class:
My 2009 Corolla XRS (2.4L I4)
0-60 Acceleration: 7.8 s
Braking: 123 ft
Curb Weight: 2952 lb
Lateral Acceleration: 0.80 g
Kia's new 2014 Forte EX (2.0L I4 GDI)
0-60 Acceleration: 7.8 s
Braking: 117ft
Curb Weight: 2944 lb
Lateral Acceleration: 0.80 g
Good old Mazda3 SkyActive (2.0L I4 "SkyActive-G")
0-60 Acceleration: 8.3 s
Braking 60-0: 120 ft
Curb Weight: 2987 lb
Lateral Acceleration: 0.79 g
And two more basic models...
A more typical 2011 Corolla LE (1.8L I4)
0-60 Acceleration: 9.8 s
Braking: 129 ft
Curb Weight: 2792 lb
Lateral Acceleration: 0.83 g
A 2014 Civic EX (1.8L I4)
0-60 Acceleration: 9.1 s
Braking: 119 ft
Curb Weight: 2826 lb
Lateral Acceleration: 0.81 g
I didn't compare fuel economy because the Corolla is still pretty much the unsophisticated winner there.... instead went for the skid pad/acceleration/braking information. Anyone trying to argue that a regular Corolla LE is the top of it's class for spirited driving is nuts but I think it's also folly to say that it's too far off either. A brand new Civic is barely any faster 0-60, only 0.02g better on a skid pad, and the extra 10 feet of braking is probably the most important (and disappointing) thing here.
I did this mostly out of curiosity but the 2009 Corolla XRS is pretty much equivalent to similarly sporty cars that just came out with the braking being the only disappointing bit but just 5 feet off of the class winner the Forte.
If it were me, and I were buying a car today in the compact sedan segment, I'd have to do the same thing as before and sit in all of them and see if the ergonomics work right for me. But the Forte and the Mazda3 are usually considered the enthusiasts choice and new models of these are the same or only marginally better than my XRS. Of course hard numbers don't always give you the "feel" of the car.
I still think it's interesting... and I also think that we're not comparing any of these to a BMW M3. But a Corolla's lifetime repair bill might be similar to just a couple of times to the service depot for one of those
Different buyers there!
EDIT: Sorry...final edit. I got everything from Motor Trend because it was easy to compare.
http://www.motortrend.com/http://www.motortrend.com/roadtests/sedans/1303_compact_sedans_the_big_test/viewall.htmlhttp://www.motortrend.com/roadtests/sedans/1105_2011_toyota_corolla_le_test/viewall.htmlhttp://www.motortrend.com/roadtests/sedans/112_0805_2009_toyota_corolla_xrs/viewall.html