On one hand, I understand ovr50's skepticism because every new performance car seems to be billed as a Bimmer-beater (didn't Pontiac once advertise the Grand Prix as out-handling the 5-Series?). And most end up not living up to that billing.
On the other hand, ovr50 sticks waaaaay too much to the "if you've never owned a BMW for a year, you're not qualified to really talk about them" fallacy, which conveniently eliminates everyone who liked a BMW competitor more than a BMW (even after lengthy test-drives) from talking about BMWs.