In the mini-ute segment, it's tough to go wrong with the Forester, CR-V or Rav4. All are well made, economical to operate (four-bangers) and have some sort of AWD system that helps out on bad roads.
The reason we bought a Forester is that they're cheaper used than either the CR-V or the Rav4. It's also a personal thing, as I like the Subie looks too. With an S-trim Forester you get four wheel discs, ABS, AWD, limited slip rear diff, heated seats, heated wiper-park, heated mirrors, in-dash 6-disc CD and nice 16" alloy wheels. The back seat is tighter than the Honda, but I didn't really care as it's plenty roomy for us. We have the OBW for carrying any fat friends that might need a lift. My wife, myself and my daughter just barely
The Subaru was the same or more moolah as the CR-V new, but does not hold it's value as well. One reason NOT to buy a new Subie over a new CR-V.