Both look great, including the wheel styling. Gorgeous, if not my favorite styles, but no matter.
However, like most if not all manufacturers, luxury is abandoned. Very disappointed. That's a whole market segment ignored when lots of available cash is being held out!
I'll explain the "most if not all" default trend these days.
It seems the better the trim/price, the more one must for whatever reason suffer the indignities of harshness to get power/handling/options/whatever. How did this dynamic evolve anyway. Even the best of them aren't track cars 90% of the time. Its implied that if a lower trim of GTi is picked, and miss all the upper trim things you want to pay for but aren't allowed to, will avoid the rubber band big wheel small sidewall. DCC is wonderful but doesn't cancel physics. Sorry.
Seems like an 18" with maybe 45 aspect ratio tires (like the GLi, GTi currently has 40 by the way) will certainly never happen in the upper sphere of GTi or R. VW may not notice because these cars could create enough buzz to increase sales vs. previous years anyway. I could buy one of these two and go minus size/aspect ratio to perhaps make a luxury car, but will it be an expensive disaster and why do I have to redesign new.
Hit the tune out loonies button.