Thanks for all the comments!
I was happy with the deal, very smooth & respectful transaction without a lot of haggling, it was 20% off MSRP plus the almost 2 additional years of warranty, and the trade value was just a little higher than I expected they would give. The extra warranty was a huge deal to me because I suspect we'll keep this one a long time.
It's hard to compare fit and finish to the Evoque because of new versus almost 5 years old, but everything is so tight and buttoned down, and the attention to detail is awesome. The infotainment makes the one in the Evoque look like a joke (same one as in the Jag and a 2008 LR2 I had way back) but I would hope the new one has improved in that area. I'm finding it really interesting to compare to just getting the vette, I can definitely see why people would pay so much more for a 911. The interior on the vette has come a long way, but it's a night/day comparison, and I'm sure that extra refinement can be felt in the drive as well. I personally love the brutish nature of the vette, but can understand it not being for everyone. There were 3 911 GT3RS in the showroom, not something I would cough up the money for, but they were damn impressive to look at!