Topic: 24 Family Sedan Comparo Test

[MKII]

This comparison looks at fully-loaded family sedans. Specifically, those from the 2008 model year  or newer that have a CarsDirect Target Price of below $28,000 while equipped with an engine that has at least 200 horsepower while mated to an automatic transmission, as well as heated power leather seats and a sunroof. The twenty-four cars that meet these criteria are listed at left.


http://ifcar.net/reviews.comparisons.familysedans.htm

[mmret]

Azera #1? Interesting, but I guess its a sensible choice depending on where you put your family car priorities.

[Zoo]

Ouch! The Chrysler Sebring gets blasted again! Man is this car ever a dud in this segment!

[rrocket]

Their methodology is flawed, because it doesn't "add up".  Add up all the scores out of ten, and some cars with a lesser total beat cars with a higher total.

Suspect methodology......

[mmret]

Their methodology is flawed, because it doesn't "add up".  Add up all the scores out of ten, and some cars with a lesser total beat cars with a higher total.

Suspect methodology......

Agreed but this segment is so cluttered that you could make a really good case for a dozen of these cars....just depends on what you like. (And this test really seems like someone just telling you what he/she "likes.")