Well, I DO own a Boxster S and (of course) it is superior to the TT. It does suck, however, to have the car mock me all winter while I drive my Audi A4 wagon into the seemingly endless Siberian-like winter. IMHO, the TT was designed to be a year-round sports car. If I had to combine both of my cars into one; I'd probably buy the TTS. Not a bad compromise for someone who goes through an Alberta winter every year.