So, last spring on this board I asked about running my Pilot Alpins through the summer on my 2000 Acura 1.6 to get the maximum mileage out of them before replacement. I tried it until June, but found that their traction in hot weather was unsafe and put on my summer tires.
I may be able to get another winter out of the Pilots, but they are now 5 yrs old with 45,000km and but I would prefer to get new ones if I find a good price here in Edmonton or at Tiretrends. Here are the options I am considering in 195/55/15:
Kumho KW17
Blizzak LM-22
W300 IceBear
Pirelli Winter210
Nokian RSI
Last year I was leaning toward the Kumhos, but reviews since have been so-so. The Nokians would be ideal here in Edmonton, but I'm not sure I want to go from an V-rated summer and H-rated winter tire down to an "R" (which is essentially a Q). Would it really mess up my handling? I wish the Dunlop M3 came in my size, but they don't.
I'd appreciate your opinions. It would be easy to just pick the best tire in the ice and snow, but, unfortunately, life in Edmonton means snowtires are on for at least 6 months and handling has to be a consideration.
Thanks,
Phil